Scout and Aunt Alexandra communicate very poorly. This is due to a number of factors, including their differing perspectives and values. Scout is a tomboy who is resistant to conformity, while Aunt Alexandra is a traditionalist who believes in the importance of refinement and social propriety.
This clash of values leads to a number of communication breakdowns between the two characters.
In this essay, we will explore the communication barriers between Scout and Aunt Alexandra. We will also discuss the impact of these barriers on their relationship and the overall dynamics of the Finch family.
Communication Barriers between Scout and Aunt Alexandra
Scout and Aunt Alexandra’s differing perspectives and values create significant communication barriers between them.
Examples of Communication Breakdowns, Scout and aunt alexandra communicate very poorly
- Aunt Alexandra’s criticism of Scout’s tomboyish behavior and insistence on using “sir” and “ma’am” highlights their contrasting values.
- Scout’s rejection of Aunt Alexandra’s attempts to “civilize” her reflects her resistance to conformity.
- Their disagreement over the Tom Robinson trial stems from their different views on race and justice.
Underlying Reasons for Barriers
- Generational differences and societal expectations.
- Aunt Alexandra’s traditional values clash with Scout’s independent spirit.
- Their differing roles within the Finch family create power imbalances.
Impact on Relationship and Family Dynamics
- Strain in their relationship and tension within the Finch household.
- Communication gaps hinder their ability to understand and support each other.
- Challenges the family’s unity and exposes underlying social divisions.
Scout’s Resistance to Conformity
Scout’s independent nature and refusal to conform to Maycomb society’s expectations are central to her character.
Examples of Resistance
- Rejects wearing dresses and playing with dolls.
- Defends Boo Radley against rumors and prejudice.
- Questions social norms and challenges authority figures.
Significance of Resistance
- Demonstrates Scout’s individuality and strength of character.
- Highlights the limitations and hypocrisy of Maycomb’s social structure.
- Challenges traditional gender roles and societal expectations.
Aunt Alexandra’s Encouragement of Refinement: Scout And Aunt Alexandra Communicate Very Poorly
Aunt Alexandra believes in the importance of refinement and social propriety, values she tries to instill in Scout.
Traditional Values
- Emphasis on proper etiquette, manners, and dress.
- Respect for social hierarchy and traditional gender roles.
- Belief in the superiority of white society.
Attempts to Instill Values
- Criticizes Scout’s behavior and appearance.
- Introduces Scout to Maycomb’s “society ladies.”
- Tries to control Scout’s interactions with Boo Radley.
Reasons for Emphasis on Refinement
- Reflects Aunt Alexandra’s social status and desire to maintain family reputation.
- Based on societal norms and expectations of Southern gentility.
- Perceived as a way to protect Scout from social ostracism.
Clash of Values and Perspectives
| Scout | Aunt Alexandra |
|---|---|
| Independent, non-conformist | Traditional, refined |
| Challenges social norms | Upholds social conventions |
| Values equality and justice | Believes in racial hierarchy |
| Compassionate towards outcasts | Judgmental of those who deviate from social norms |
Contribution to Communication Difficulties
- Their contrasting values create fundamental disagreements.
- Aunt Alexandra’s attempts to impose her values on Scout stifle communication.
- Scout’s resistance to conformity further exacerbates their communication gap.
Evolution of Their Relationship
Scout and Aunt Alexandra’s relationship evolves throughout the novel, marked by both positive and negative shifts.
Key Moments of Change
- Scout’s defense of Boo Radley brings them closer.
- Aunt Alexandra’s disapproval of Scout’s friendship with Walter Cunningham creates tension.
- Scout’s realization of Aunt Alexandra’s loneliness leads to a newfound understanding.
Factors Contributing to Evolution
- Scout’s growing maturity and understanding.
- Aunt Alexandra’s recognition of Scout’s strength and independence.
- Shared experiences and challenges.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do Scout and Aunt Alexandra communicate so poorly?
Scout and Aunt Alexandra communicate so poorly because of their differing perspectives and values. Scout is a tomboy who is resistant to conformity, while Aunt Alexandra is a traditionalist who believes in the importance of refinement and social propriety.
What impact does this communication breakdown have on their relationship?
This communication breakdown has a negative impact on their relationship. It leads to misunderstandings, arguments, and resentment.
How does this communication breakdown affect the overall dynamics of the Finch family?
This communication breakdown affects the overall dynamics of the Finch family by creating tension and conflict between Scout and Aunt Alexandra. This tension and conflict can spill over into other relationships within the family.
